The ultimate Stay Interview toolkit: everything you need to retain top talents

By Nadya H

This article will help you conduct stay interviews effectively - a structured conversation between a manager and an employee to identify the factors that motivate the employee to stay with the organization.

In today's competitive job market, retaining employees has become increasingly important. The cost of replacing an employee can be high and can negatively impact the morale and productivity of the remaining staff. 

According to a 2021 Gallup survey, 52% of voluntarily leaving employees believe their manager or company might have taken action to keep them on the job. Before an employee leaves the building, organizations can identify that "something" by conducting stay interviews. As a result, many organizations have turned to stay interviews to engage and retain their employees.

A stay interview is a structured conversation between a manager and an employee to identify the factors that motivate and engage the employee to stay with the organization. Research from the Workforce Institute at UKG outlines that 74% of staff who felt listened to by their employer were more engaged at work and effective in their role. The interview aims to understand the employee's needs and desires, address any concerns they may have, and ultimately increase their commitment to the organization.

In this blog, we'll introduce you to the ultimate stay interview toolkit that will equip you with all the necessary tools and techniques to conduct effective stay interviews. By implementing these strategies, you'll be able to retain your top talent and improve employee engagement, resulting in increased productivity, better job satisfaction, and higher employee retention rates.


Importance of a stay interview toolkit

Stay interviews are an effective way for organizations to retain their top employees and ensure that they are satisfied with their jobs. A stay interview toolkit is a set of resources that can help organizations conduct successful stay interviews.

Here are some of the reasons why a stay interview toolkit is essential:-

1. Retention

Stay interviews can help organizations identify issues or concerns that might cause employees to leave. Organizations can increase their retention rates by addressing these problems.

2. Employee experience (EX)

They can help organizations understand what motivates their employees and what they value about their jobs. Organizations may increase employee engagement and happiness by addressing these elements.

3. Performance

Managers can spot areas where staff members require more coaching or assistance. Performance and productivity may increase as a result of this.

4. Culture

Stay interviews can help organizations identify cultural issues affecting employee satisfaction. Organizations can create a more uplifting and diverse workplace culture by addressing these problems.

A stay interview toolkit can help organizations prepare for and conduct effective stay interviews and ensure that they are maximizing the benefits of this valuable retention tool.

how-to-foster-an-employee-centric-cultureSource: AIHR

The essential components of a comprehensive stay interview toolkit

A stay interview is a structured conversation between an employer and an employee designed to identify and address issues contributing to employee turnover. A comprehensive stay interview toolkit should include the following components:

Stay interview questions

The toolkit should contain a list of well-crafted questions designed to elicit candid responses from employees about their job satisfaction, motivation, career aspirations, and any issues they may be experiencing.

Interview guide 

A stay interview guide can help managers and supervisors conduct stay interviews in a consistent and structured way. It should provide tips on asking open-ended questions, active listening skills, and following up on responses.

Feedback forms

Feedback forms are a valuable tool for documenting the feedback received during the stay interview. They should include sections for recording responses to the interview questions and for reporting any follow-up actions that are agreed upon.

Action planning template

An action planning template can help managers and employees work together to develop a plan for addressing any issues identified during the stay interview. The template should include sections for identifying goals, actions to be taken, and timelines for completion.

Training materials

Managers and supervisors may require training on how to conduct stay interviews effectively. The toolkit should include training materials such as guides, videos, and training sessions that cover the critical skills required to conduct successful stay interviews.

Performance metrics

The toolkit should include metrics for measuring the success of the stay interview program, such as employee retention rates, employee engagement scores, and employee satisfaction scores.


CTA-Banner-EX Guide


Best practices for using the stay interview toolkit

Here are some best practices for using the stay interview toolkit effectively:

1. Set clear goals

Before conducting a stay interview, establish the objectives you want to achieve. Identify the questions you want to ask and the specific feedback you hope to receive.

2. Ensure confidentiality

Employees must feel safe and secure while sharing their concerns. Therefore, it's essential to maintain the confidentiality of the information provided during the stay interview.

3. Train your managers

Managers who conduct stay interviews should be trained to handle difficult situations and professionally respond to employees' feedback.

4. Conduct the stay interview regularly

To make it effective, conduct the stay interview regularly. It helps identify employees' issues and concerns at an early stage.

5. Use open-ended questions

This will encourage employees to share their thoughts, feelings, and opinions freely. 

6. Follow-up

After conducting a stay interview, following up with employees to address their concerns and suggestions is essential. This demonstrates that their feedback is valuable.

7. Act on the feedback

Use the feedback from the stay interview to make changes and improvements in the workplace. If the feedback is not acted upon, it will only lead to frustration and dissatisfaction among employees.

8. Track progress

Track progress and monitor employee satisfaction to ensure the effectiveness of the stay interview. It's essential to measure the impact of changes made in response to feedback received.

đź’ˇ Looking for a better way to measure employee satisfaction? 

See how our platform can help you gain insights about your workforce by collecting employee feedback.


Using stay interview data

Stay interview data can be used in several ways to improve employee experience, retention, and organizational performance. By looking for patterns and trends in the responses, managers can identify areas where employees may be dissatisfied or at risk of leaving. Organizations can use the data to identify and address specific employee concerns. Consider implementing changes or improvements to address the concerns and improve employee retention. After making changes based on the stay interview data, follow up with employees to ensure that they are satisfied with the changes and that their concerns have been addressed.

Many businesses have successfully used data from stay interviews to boost productivity and staff retention. Here are a few examples:

  1. Deloitte - Deloitte found through stay interviews that their employees wanted more flexibility and work-life balance. In response, they implemented flexible work arrangements and created a culture of work-life balance. This has resulted in increased employee satisfaction and retention.

  2. Zappos - Zappos used stay interviews to understand their employees' needs and wants. They discovered that employees valued opportunities for growth and development, so Zappos implemented a program called "Zapponians," which provides employees with leadership development opportunities.

  3. Google- Google implemented stay interviews as part of its retention strategy. They found that employees were leaving because they didn't feel valued or recognized for their work. In response, Google implemented a peer-to-peer recognition program called "gThanks" which allows employees to recognize and appreciate each other's work. Employee retention and satisfaction have grown as a result.


Overcoming challenges

Conducting stay interviews can sometimes present challenges. Here are some strategies to overcome common challenges:

1. Employees may feel hesitant to be completely honest

Employees may be hesitant to share their thoughts and feelings during a stay interview, fearing that it may impact their job security or performance evaluation. To overcome this difficulty, maintain confidentiality and secrecy. EngageRocket's employee engagement platform is designed to ensure anonymity and encourage honest feedback. We use advanced data encryption and security measures to protect employee data. Creating a safe and confidential space empowers employees to share their thoughts and feelings, leading to more accurate and insightful feedback.

2. Interviewer bias

Interviewers may have unconscious biases that can impact the results of the stay interview. To overcome this challenge, ensure that the interviewer is trained to conduct the stay interview and to remain objective throughout the process. It is also recommended to use a standardized set of questions to ensure consistency and reduce the impact of interviewer bias.

3. Lack of action or follow-up

Conducting a stay interview and not taking any action to address the concerns or suggestions of the employee can lead to disillusionment and decreased trust in the organization. To overcome this challenge, create an action plan to address the concerns raised during the interview and provide regular feedback to employees about the progress being made.

4. Limited time or resources

Conducting stay interviews can be time-consuming and resource-intensive, particularly in large organizations. To overcome this challenge, consider conducting stay interviews regularly, focusing on specific departments or teams at a time. Also, consider using platforms such as EngageRocket technology, such as survey software to automate the process and make it more efficient.


CTA-Banner-EX Guide


Conclusion on making the best out of your stay interview toolkit

In conclusion, stay interviews are valuable for organizations to understand their employees' needs and motivations. They help identify the factors that can drive retention and engagement and address concerns before they become major problems. Stay interviews create a platform for employees to express their views and feel valued, ultimately contributing to higher job satisfaction and productivity. 

EngageRocket helps with stay interviews and employee retention by providing a platform for managers to gather employee feedback on their experience and engagement within the company. With this information, managers can identify areas for improvement and develop strategies to address any concerns, ultimately improving employee satisfaction and retention. Additionally, EngageRocket's analytics can help you gain insights about your employees, allowing managers to proactively address any issues before they lead to turnover.


Want more content like this?

Join EngageRocket's HR Impact community and get the latest HR resources and exclusive event invites!




What questions are asked in a stay interview?

Stay interviews are conducted to understand the employee's experience and their reasons for staying in their current role. Some of the common questions asked in a stay interview include:

  1. What do you like best about your job and the organization?

  2. What drives you to continue working in your current capacity?

  3. What difficulties do you encounter in your position, and how can we support you in overcoming them?

  4. How can we assist you in attaining your professional objectives?

  5. What modifications would you like made to your job or the organization?

  6. Do you feel that your efforts are respected and acknowledged?

  7. Do you feel you have an excellent work-life balance?

  8. How can we make your workplace or culture better?

  9. Are you worried about your job or the company?

  10. What can we do to increase your commitment and engagement at work?


How do you implement a stay interview?

Here are some steps to implement a stay interview:

  1. Plan ahead: Decide who will conduct the stay interview, the format of the interview, and the questions to ask.

  2. Choose the right timing: Schedule the stay interview when the employee is not under stress or pressure, and give them enough time to prepare.

  3. Create a comfortable environment: Choose a location where the employee will feel comfortable and relaxed.

  4. Ask open-ended questions: Ask questions that allow the employee to share their thoughts and feelings about their job, the company culture, their team, and their goals.

  5. Pay close attention: Take close attention to the employee's remarks and jot down if needed.

  6. Following up: Recap the interview discussion and review any issues or ideas with the employee. Any actions suggested during the stay interview should be followed up on.


Who should perform stay interviews?

HR leaders or a designated employee engagement team can conduct stay interviews. However, it is important that the person conducting the stay interview has a good rapport with the employee and is trusted by them. Ideally, the person should understand the employee's job responsibilities, challenges, and work environment well.

The stay interview aims to gather honest employee feedback about their job satisfaction, career goals, and overall experience at the company. Therefore, the interviewer should be skilled in active listening and communication to ensure that employees feel comfortable sharing their thoughts and opinions.


When should you do a stay interview?

Ideally, a stay interview must be held before an employee displays signs of disinterest or decides to quit. Conducting the interview at least once a year to check in with employees, gather feedback, and make improvements to retain top talent is recommended. The best time to conduct a stay interview would be when an employee has completed a significant project or has achieved a milestone. It allows them to celebrate their success and address any concerns. Additionally, if an organization is experiencing changes or transitioning, conducting a stay interview can help retain employees by addressing their concerns and ensuring their engagement.

CTA-Banner-EX Guide


Tags: Managing People, Employee Experience